Shopping for a new vehicle can be exciting, but it can also feel overwhelming. You’re not just looking for a car that fits your budget today—you’re thinking about maintenance costs and future resale value. Finding a vehicle that requires minimal repairs while holding its value well is challenging, but not impossible. Here are four cars that stand out for their reliability and strong resale performance.
Toyota Tacoma: The Toyota Tacoma is a midsize pickup truck that consistently earns high marks for its toughness and long-term value retention.
For 2025, the Tacoma starts at $31,590, and after five years, it retains approximately 67% of its original value, according to Joe Giranda, Director of Sales and Marketing for CFR Classic.
“The annual repair cost is around $673, and major repairs are rare, with only an 18.5% chance over 10 years,” Giranda explains. “Its reliability comes from a strong suspension system and a straightforward design, enhanced by Toyota’s Safety Sense features.”
Honda Civic: A well-known favorite, the Honda Civic is a smart choice for budget-conscious drivers who want reliability and value.
Starting at $24,250, the Civic retains 62.5% of its value after five years. Owners spend an average of $368 per year on repairs, making it one of the most affordable cars to maintain, according to Giranda.
“This reliability is primarily due to efficient engines and a quality build,” he explains. “The Civic continues to stand out as an excellent buy in its class.”
Subaru Outback: The Subaru Outback is another top performer when it comes to resale value and dependability.
For 2025, the Outback starts at $29,010 and retains roughly 70% of its original worth after five years. The annual repair cost averages $847, but major repairs remain unlikely over a 10-year period.
“The Outback’s spacious, technologically advanced interior, combined with its superior symmetrical AWD and drivetrain, makes it a truly reliable vehicle,” Giranda notes.
Toyota 4Runner: The Toyota 4Runner continues to be a top SUV choice, thanks to its legendary durability and off-road capability.
With a starting MSRP of $40,770 for the 2025 model, the 4Runner retains about 69.8% of its value after five years, losing only 30.2% of its worth—one of the best resale values in the SUV category.
“Owners spend around $514 annually on repairs, and the risk of major breakdowns is very low due to its sturdy body-on-frame construction,” says Giranda. “Its off-roading capabilities, spacious interiors, and strong resale value justify its premium price.”
Find the Best Deals on New & Used Cars
Ready to find a great deal on one of these top-performing vehicles? Head over to Quotes.EverymanDriver.com to access real-time dealer pricing on both new and used cars in your area. This free search engine is used by thousands of car shoppers every day to compare prices and save hundreds, even thousands, of dollars on their next vehicle. Don’t overpay—start your search today and find the lowest prices available!
